Bella Thorne’s Open Relationship with Tana Mongeau and Mod Sun

Bella Thorne’s Journey Into Openness: Challenging Traditional Relationship Labels

Actress, singer, and author Bella Thorne has long been known for her candid honesty and fearless approach to both art and life. Over the past years, her romantic life has broken through Hollywood’s usual boxes and given her a unique role in spotlighting what it means to love openly and on your own terms. Thorne’s relationships with Tana Mongeau and Mod Sun have become emblematic of this new, open-minded approach, inviting fans — and critics — to rethink what it means to be in love, and who gets to tell the story.

Bella Thorne, Tana Mongeau, & Mod Sun: An Overview of Their Relationship

In Hollywood, the stories we hear are often those that reinforce familiar scripts: monogamy, heteronormativity, and clarity in labels. Bella Thorne’s high-profile relationships with YouTuber and social media personality Tana Mongeau, alongside musician Mod Sun, quietly began to change this narrative. Thorne, Mongeau, and Mod Sun spent over a year in a relationship that openly challenged assumptions about sexuality, gender, and the need for fixed identifiers.

The trio’s dynamic first drew public attention in late 2017, when Thorne and Mongeau began sharing affectionate posts on social media, sometimes featuring Mod Sun. Thorne’s willingness to engage in public discussions — often controversial — helped spark conversations about polyamory and sexual fluidity in both fan circles and the broader media.

Highlights of Their Relationship

• Public Acknowledgment: Thorne and Mongeau confirmed their relationship during September 2017, while Thorne was simultaneously dating Mod Sun.
• Open Discussions: Both Mongeau and Thorne have spoken in interviews and YouTube videos about the complexities, lessons, and emotions involved in an open relationship.
• Breakup: Thorne and Mongeau publicly announced their breakup in February 2019, though they maintained public and sometimes contentious interactions afterward.

Bella Thorne on Fluidity, Labels, and Love

One of the core aspects of Thorne’s approach to her romantic life is her resistance to labels, boxes, and the need for easy categorization. In interviews, such as with Gay Times, Thorne has emphasized the freedom she finds in not conforming to societal expectations regarding sexuality and relationships.

“In this world, it’s like you’re either gay or you’re straight; there’s no in between… If you f* a guy once, you must be gay. Like, what? No. That’s just being fluid. It’s not a gay or straight box. It’s this middle in-between world that nobody can put in a box, which makes them so mad.”

Thorne stresses that not “boxing in” relationships or individuals allows for greater authenticity and happiness. Her comments highlight how public scrutiny often craves clear definitions, yet people themselves may find genuine connection outside these traditional boxes.

Core Opinions from Thorne on Relationships

• Refusal to Label: Thorne and her partners “don’t put a word, a box, or label too many things. It is what it is.”
• Celebrating Fluidity: She considers herself sexually fluid and sees value in relationships that don’t demand conformity or rigid boundaries.
• Media & Public Perception: She recognizes that outsiders often “hate on” what they cannot categorize, but she remains unapologetic about living authentically.

The Public’s Fascination: Polyamory in the Spotlight

Thorne’s relationship wasn’t just personal; it became increasingly public as details unfolded in interviews, Instagram stories, and news articles. Many in the LGBTQ+ community and beyond saw her openness as both bold and educational.

Her words, and the relationship itself, challenged conventions about polyamory, prompting both praise and criticism in equal measure. Discussions ranged from supportive encouragement for more visibility to skepticism about whether celebrities should lead by example if their actions might reinforce negative stereotypes. Yet, as Thorne and Mongeau both made clear, what mattered was not the critics, but the authenticity they felt with each other and Mod Sun.

Tana Mongeau’s Perspective

Mongeau has reflected that, at first, there was tension — especially between her and Mod Sun — but over time, their relationship with Thorne became “so harmonious and absolutely normal to us.” She has credited this period with teaching her a great deal about herself, about polyamory, and about how openness can stretch and redefine what commitment means.

Breaking Stereotypes: Bisexuality, Fluidity, and Public Discourse

Throughout her public appearances and interviews, Thorne’s focus on fluidity has highlighted a frequently overlooked reality: bisexuality and sexual fluidity remain widely misunderstood. The tendency to view experiences as either/or — either gay or straight, either monogamous or single — frequently leads to the erasure of those who live in the “middle in-between world.”

Thorne’s insistence on living openly, and her outspokenness about not conforming, make her an important figure in discussions about sexual identity today.

• Visibility: Greater public discussion can break down harmful stereotypes and invite new understanding.
• Authenticity Over Labels: By refusing to conform, Thorne provides a visible model of how to thrive outside additional boxes.

Influence On Fans and Community

The ripple effects of Thorne’s relationship choices are visible not just in media coverage, but also in fan communities. Many young followers have shared stories of feeling “seen” and empowered to challenge narrow expectations in their own lives.

Drama, Reactions, and The End of an Era

No Hollywood story is complete without drama, and the eventual transitions within Thorne, Mongeau, and Mod Sun’s relationships have played out on social platforms, often with remarkable candor. In early 2019, Thorne and Mongeau announced the end of their romantic involvement, with Thorne writing on Twitter, “Tana and I are no longer good. She broke girl code I’m over it.” Public spats, cryptic tweets, and emotional Instagram stories captured both the pain and intensity of ending a relationship in the spotlight.

Not long later, Mongeau became engaged to YouTuber Jake Paul, leading to further feelings broadcast across social channels, including Thorne’s Instagram stories and reactions that went viral.

Public Confrontations

• Twitter Drama: Both parties aired grievances publicly, highlighting the challenge of navigating former romantic bonds in an ultra-visible way.
• Reactions to Engagement: Thorne posted a pointed, emotional response to the news of Mongeau’s new engagement — demonstrating that love, even when open and fluid, is subject to heartbreak and jealousy.

Reflections: Lessons on Love, Openness, and Self-Discovery

The aftermath of Bella Thorne’s open relationship is as instructive as the years that preceded it. Both Thorne and Mongeau have reiterated the lessons learned: about themselves, about the possibilities and challenges of open relationships, and about the ongoing struggle to reject labels imposed from the outside. Mongeau has described the relationship as a key period of growth, and Thorne continues to use her platform to advocate for honesty, self-acceptance, and expansive definitions of love.

Key Takeaways from Bella Thorne’s Perspective

• Reject external labels and societal pressure: embrace authenticity above convention.
• Communication and honesty remain crucial, regardless of relationship structure.
• Even progressive relationships can encounter traditional problems (e.g., jealousy, public scrutiny, “girl code” controversies).

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is an open relationship?

An open relationship is a romantic arrangement where all parties consent to one or more partners having emotional or sexual relationships outside the primary partnership.

Did Bella Thorne, Tana Mongeau, and Mod Sun identify as polyamorous?

Although Bella and her partners sometimes joked about being “poly,” Bella was clear that they refused to strictly label their connection, preferring to describe their bond without putting it “in a word, a box, or label.”

Why did Bella Thorne and Tana Mongeau break up?

The specific reasons remain private, but the breakup played out publicly through social media posts and comments referencing hurt feelings, broken “girl code,” and new romantic entanglements, especially following Mongeau’s engagement to Jake Paul.

What impact did Bella Thorne’s open relationship have on conversations around bisexuality and polyamory?

Bella Thorne’s openness brought increased visibility to bisexual and polyamorous relationships, both by modeling alternatives to traditional labels and by publicly discussing the complexities and social challenges faced by people outside the mainstream.

Table: Bella Thorne, Tana Mongeau, and Mod Sun – Major Relationship Events

Challenging Relationship Norms: The Broader Impact

Bella Thorne’s candidness about her relationships with Tana Mongeau and Mod Sun has done more than capture headlines — it has offered a real-world example of how people can create their own romantic paradigms. Rejecting the pressure to fit into neat categories, Thorne’s journey serves as a mirror for many who also resist easily defined boxes.

By speaking openly about her experiences, both the joyful and the painful, Thorne has advanced the conversation about acceptance, authenticity, and the honest messiness of love.

• Sexuality and Labels: Her words force a reconsideration of who gets to define identity, and how personal happiness often resists categorization.
• Relationship Diversity: The highly-visible nature of her relationships amplifies a call for greater openness to diverse ways of loving.

Further Reading and Support Resources

• GLAAD: Information and support on LGBTQ+ issues and visibility
• Polyamory Society: Educational resources on non-monogamous relationships
• Gay Times: Interviews and coverage of LGBTQ+ celebrity stories

Always remember:

• Your relationship does not need to fit anyone else’s model to be real or valuable.
• It is healthy to resist labels if they do not feel authentic to your experience.
• Openness and communication are critical in any relationship, monogamous or not.